Temptation (The Hunted, #1)(62)
"You're mine," he growled.
I felt a pang of guilt about Tyler, but the thought quickly disappeared as Professor Hunter thrust himself deep inside me again.
"Yes! I'm yours!" I moaned.
The windows were soon completely fogged up besides for my handprint. Professor Hunter continued to guide my hips, going faster and faster.
"Come for me, Penny." He lifted his hips slightly, pressing his erection into a spot that I didn't even know existed. Oh God! The sensation made my whole body shake.
"Professor Hunter!" I clenched myself around him as his hot cum shot through me. He pulsed inside of me, again and again.
I collapsed on top of him. He kissed the top of my head and wrapped his arms around me.
Chapter 42
Sunday
I reread my speech again and took a deep breath. My stomach was in knots, and not just because of the speech. Professor Hunter had finally opened up to me, and I was the one that was still hiding the truth from him. He probably wouldn't want anything to do with me once he found out I was only 19. And then there was Tyler. How could I have feelings for two men at once? My room felt hot. I put my hair into a ponytail and started to read my speech again.
"That's quite the hickey, Penny," Melissa said.
"What?" I ran over to the mirror. "Shit." I tilted my head and looked at the small bruise on my neck. I quickly pulled my hair tie out and let my hair fall over the dark spot.
"So you hung out with Tyler again last night, huh?"
I began to blush. "No, last night I was talking to Pro...choo!" I tried to cover up my mistake with a fake sneeze. I added a light cough. There were too many secrets, and too many things to remember. "I must be getting a cold or something. No, last night I was following your advice and talking to James."
"Penny, you've gone from future cat lady to quite the slut."
I put my hand over my hickey. "Melissa!"
"I'm just messing with you. But really, do they both know about each other now? You're allowed to date more than one person at a time, but you should probably be upfront about it. James really must be sexy as hell because Tyler is hot...like really hot."
I sat back down on my bed. "I don't think I know how to date two people at once. And I don't think I want to. What should I do?"
"Make a pro-con list?" Melissa grabbed a sheet of paper. "Okay, pros for James?"
"Well, he really is sexy. And he's sweet. He's also very mature. And I have so much fun when I'm with him. He's so spontaneous."
"Penny, you're forgetting that James is loaded. Money is definitely a pro, even if you don't think so."
I winced. "That's really not important to me.
Melissa rolled her eyes. "Too late, it's on the list. Now Tyler."
"Tyler is really sweet too and sexy. But he's also a great friend. He's thoughtful and he's definitely patient. He's a really nice guy."
"Okay, cons for James?"
"James can be pretty controlling." Or is that a pro? I felt myself blushing. "He kind of has a bad temper and he is quite a bit older. He can be pretty mysterious at times too." And he's my professor, I have to keep our relationship a secret, and I have to lie constantly.
"Isn't him being mysterious a good thing? I feel like that probably makes him even sexier."
I shrugged. "I don't like that he's held things back from me." But he just told me his secrets. We're in a good place.
"Cons for Tyler?"
"Well, he's graduating soon. So I don't really know what his plans are after school."
"And?"
"I don't know. Tyler is really nice. There aren't any other cons I can think of."
Melissa held up the list. "James definitely has more cons than Tyler."
I bit my lip. Of course James had more cons than Tyler.
"Well I think you know how you feel now."
"What?"
"Penny, you look like you're in pain."
I shook my head. "No, it's just...all those different points aren't even with each other. Some things are more important than others."
Melissa put the paper down. "I think I know what this is about. It's the sex, isn't it?"
"No!" I bit my lip again. "I don't know. It's just that James...he makes me feel...ugh," I put my face in my hands.
"Okay, so the sex is amazing. And what about Tyler?"
"We haven't done that."
"You're joking."
"No."
"So maybe that's your answer. You need to have sex with Tyler and then you can properly decide."
"I can't do that to James."
"You were about to on Friday when I walked in on you guys."
"But that was before I talked to James."
"Well, the answer seems pretty obvious then. It's James. Clearly it's always been James."
***
I sat at my desk hoping that the speech before mine would never end. Because as soon as it did, I was up. I glanced down at the outfit I had worn to try to impress Professor Hunter. Or is it Tyler? Either way, it was too much. My tank top combined with my pushup bra showed entirely too much cleavage, and my skirt was too tight and too short. I don't know how high the heels were, but they were definitely too high for me to comfortably walk in. Why did I choose this outfit?