Infini (Aerial Ethereal #2)(51)

My lips almost pull upward because I love that he still does.

“The extraterrestrial experience,” he tells the waitress.

“I’m good with a coffee,” I say, and as she leaves, I lean over the table and peer at his menu. We both read the description of the food called extraterrestrial experience, and I start laughing loudly.

“Fuck,” he laughs with me. He just ordered a deep-fried Moon Pie.

“I know you’ll still eat it.” I laugh harder, not wanting to lean back just yet.

“Will I?” he teases. “I could be a picky eater now, and you wouldn’t know it.” He meant it to be lighthearted, especially since I’ve seen him eat the same stuff he used to: candy, pizza, huge hamburgers, you name it—all in the past ten days. But an undercurrent of sadness clings to his statement.

“That’s true.” I lower my ass to the seat.

“That was stupid. I’m the same,” he says, more serious. “I promise, I’m the same.”

He’s had nearly half a decade without me. After what happened to us, how could we both be the same? Parts of us did change, but if I could choose anyone to let discover me and for me to be able to discover them, I’d choose Luka.

So I pick up my journal. With a deep breath, I start, “You were my first everything. And then, it just…ended.”

“You were my first too,” he reminds me.

This is going to hurt. “Did you have a second?” I ask outright.

Luka leans back like he got kicked in the stomach. He snuffs out his cigarette in an alien-head ashtray, and then he rakes another hand through his hair.

Yes, his silence says. He did.

My limbs are achingly strict.

“A third? A fourth?” I pause for him to interject, and my throat nearly swells closed. “A fifth? A sixth—”

“It was five years.” He shakes his head repeatedly. “I didn’t think I’d ever be able to look at you or even say your name. If I knew we’d be here, right now, I’d have…” he trails off, because it’s too painful to rewrite history like that.

“I’m not admonishing you.”

“Admonishing.” He laughs into a smile. We shouldn’t be able to go from severity to mirth this quickly, but we do. We did.

All the time.

I try to restrain another smile, and then I groan because it won’t stop growing.

“You still look at that thesaurus, don’t you?” he asks, good memories illuminating his features. We both sucked at Aerial Ethereal’s version of high school English, and they gave us thesauruses because we kept reusing the same words in essays. I was actually more interested in mine than Luka ever thought I’d be.

“I like looking at your doodles,” I say seriously. He drew all over the margins of mine. Mostly of stick figures doing cartwheels and backflips. Some of us holding hands.

Sappy teenage moments that I wouldn’t even consider erasing.

“You’ll have to show me them sometime.” He glances over his shoulder like he gathers his thoughts or strength, and when he looks back, his face is stoic but still breakable. “Did you have a second?”

“I tried dating. A lot in the past couple of years.”

He cringes like it’s hard to hear.

I know the feeling. I open my journal so I can explain better.

Luka shifts in the booth, and his gaze narrows at the frosted window. A green neon sign blinks open from inside. “Did you fall in love?”

That’s what he’s really worried about? If I fell in love? “No,” I whisper. “Did you?”

“No,” he says. “You’re the only one.” He licks his lips. “You’re single?”

I nod.

“No friends-with-benefits?” he asks what I asked him in my suite.

“None.”

He tries to relax, and he glances at my journal, noticing my handwriting. It’s not a funny list.

It’s not a joke or surface-level emotions. What I wrote is intimate. It’s something I haven’t even shared with Aunt Lucy. And I definitely wouldn’t show this to Brenden.

My stomach clenches. I’m really scared, but I don’t want to back out. “I meant to show this to you earlier today, but you were late and things just spiraled in a weird direction.”

“I was trying to get my brother off the roulette table.”

“Timo?”

“Yeah.” Luka nods. “I pulled him away when he was four-hundred down.”

“Ouch.”

“It’s not the worst,” he tells me.

It’s just another indication that I haven’t been fully a part of his life recently. I want to be. I want to be so badly, and I ache for him to be a part of mine again.

My list inside the journal is a step towards something more. It’s opening a door that’s been slammed shut. It’s not exactly hope since the contracts still remain fixed, but it’s a hand reaching out to him.

Luka fiddles with the sugar packets. “What is it? The journal, I mean.”

“It’s a list.” It needs more context so I add, “I’ve wanted to move forward, but every time I try, I just…something happens. I’m having trouble in an area—”

“Romantic,” he states.