So Many Boys (The Naughty List #2)(30)

I smiled and closed up the empty box, setting our plates on top. Then I climbed up to sit across from him on the couch. It was time to get down to business. “So,” I said. “What did you want to talk about?”

Joel flinched, almost like he was hoping I wouldn’t bring it up.

“I feel stupid now,” he said, closing his eyes. “I shouldn’t be bothering you with this stuff. You have your own problems.”

I sure did.

“But it’s Kira. I…I don’t know what’s going on with us.” When Joel’s soft hazel eyes met mine, I could see how sad he was. He truly cared about Kira. What was her deal? Didn’t she know how hard love was to come by these days? She was totally fouling out!

I rested my head against the back of the sofa, thinking. “What happened tonight?” I asked.

He exhaled. “Well, we were supposed to meet for dinner. Then she shows up late, all frazzled, and says that her cheers were completely ‘effed’ and that she had to meet with Leona tonight to go over them.”

The pineapples turned in my stomach. The squad was continuing to leave me out. I felt my own eyes sting with tears.

“So I asked her if she wanted to grab something from the drive-through, and she tells me she’s already eaten! I mean, I was waiting for her, Tessa!” Joel’s voice took on an edge, and to be honest, it was kind of hot. It was a real moment—a moment where you could see someone’s passion. I blinked heavily.

“Tessa?” he asked softly, meeting my stare. “Do…do you think she’s cheating on me?”

Fudge ripple! Was he serious? “No way! Kittens don’t cheat!”

Joel tilted his head in complete confusion. “Uh . . . okay. Is that like part of your cheerleader pledge or something?”

Right. I sometimes forgot that people didn’t know we were SOS. “Yes,” I said confidently. “And Kira’s been through a lot. With a lot of guys.” Joel looked a little sick.

Oops. I also sometimes forgot that not everyone knew about Kira’s promiscuous past.

“What I mean is…” I paused, not wanting to do any more damage. I sighed. “She loves you,” I said simply. “She just does.” I smiled. “And I can see why. You’re an awfully nice guy, Joel. Kira’s a lucky girl, and she’s not likely to forget it.” There. That sounded much better.

Joel watched me carefully, his crooked tooth peeking out just a little beneath his parted lips. It was his little quirks—the tooth, the T-shirts, the…non-fishing—that made him that little bit of extra cool. “And you’re a nice girl too,” he said. “Despite what they say.”

“What?” My heart jumped in my throat.

“I’m kidding,” he said, laughing. “Wow, Tessa. You really need to work on your sense of sarcasm.”

I didn’t tell him that I found sarcasm rude.

“God,” he said, glancing down at the shiny silver watch on his arm. “It’s getting late. I should go.”

“Oh.” I was disappointed. I liked having the company.

He paused as he stood. “Unless there was something you wanted to talk about?”

Joel was such a mind reader! There was a lot I needed to talk about, but most of it was top secret. No. I needed to talk the Mary thing over with the squad, and only the squad. Or at least, I would if they ever decided to let me in their loop again.

“I’m fine,” I said, standing up to walk him out. “But I’ll let you know if something comes up.”

Joel looked down at me, narrowing his eyes. “You’re a mysterious girl, Tessa Crimson. And very interesting. I hope your boyfriend comes to his senses soon.”

“Thanks.” I wished he would too.

As Joel and I crossed the living room into the kitchen, he snapped his fingers. “Wait, I almost forgot!”

“What?” I looked at the sofa but didn’t see anything.

“I’ll be right back,” he said, jogging quickly out the front door.

I peeked out the front-hall window to see Joel reach in the passenger side of his car, light up its interior, and grab something on the floor. Then he slammed the door shut and ran back over to me.

“For you,” he said, extending a small, square package in one arm. I looked down, and my stomach fluttered.

“My book?” It was the lavender-covered mystery novel!

“Yep. You left it on my pile of novels, so I bought it for you. You were sort of a blubbery mess.”

I blinked, turning the book over in my hands, and then glanced at him. “Thank you.” An overwhelming mix of feeling rushed through me. I wanted to both laugh and cry because at that moment, I felt special. Not invisible.

“Anytime,” Joel said quietly, giving me a smile as he backed slowly toward his car. “I’ll talk with you again soon, okay?”

I nodded, waving once to him. I liked Joel. In fact, he might be exactly the sort of friend I needed right now. Someone that didn’t judge me. Didn’t—

My cell phone vibrated in my pocket, making me jump. I moved back inside the house, turning the dead bolt on my front door before pulling out my phone. It was Kira.

“Hey,” I said, exhaling. “I’ve been trying to call you.”

“I saw that. Sorry. Hey, I’m just around the corner at Taco Bell with Leona and Izzie. Can we stop by?”