Harbor Street (Cedar Cove #5)(70)

Holding back a smile, Grace said airily, “Oh, just that you love him.”

Olivia’s eyes narrowed. “I’m reconsidering that. In all my born days, I’ve never known a man as pigheaded as Jack Griffin.”

Grace would hear none of it. “You’re crazy about this man. You love him—you can’t help loving him.”

To her surprise, Olivia laughed. “I do, and he knows it.”

A smug look came over Jack. “The thing is, I love her, too.” He held out his hand to Olivia, who clasped it firmly. “I’m sorry, sweetheart.”

“Me, too.” She sniffled, then abruptly went back to the kitchen.

“We argue,” Jack said. “I don’t think she’s used to that.”

“She isn’t,” Grace told him. Her friend, the judge, liked order and control; she rarely raised her voice or lost her cool. Marrying Jack had changed all that.

“But we make up, too,” Jack added. “That’s the best part.” He jiggled his eyebrows for effect.

Grace smiled. Her friend’s marriage might not be perfect, but she’d never seen Olivia happier. Jack was exactly the kind of man she needed in her life—irreverent, confrontational and fun.

“The tea will be ready in a minute,” Olivia said from the kitchen.

Jack’s eyes softened and he seemed to have forgotten that Grace was in the room. After a moment, he said, “I was sorry to hear about you and Cliff.”

Rather than comment, Grace nodded. It still hurt to think about Cliff. Much as she wanted to, she couldn’t dismiss him completely from her thoughts. In time, she reasoned, that would get easier.

“Things just didn’t work out,” she said as if it were a minor occurrence.

Olivia returned then, carrying a tray with three filled cups and a plate of oatmeal cookies.

“None for you,” she announced to Jack the instant his eyes widened with delight.

“This is cruel and unusual punishment,” he growled.

“The doctor wants you down twenty-five pounds.”

“Who made you the diet police?”

“I did. Do you want to argue some more?” she asked as she passed him a cup of tea.

“No, but it’s downright mean of you to tempt me.”

Olivia sighed. “All right, you can have one cookie.”

As soon as Jack set down the tea, he grabbed Olivia about the waist and pulled her onto his lap.

She let out a squeal of protest, then threw her arms around his neck. “Do I need to remind you we have company?” she asked.

“Am I embarrassing you?” Jack asked his wife.

“Terribly.”

He grinned as if that had been his purpose all along. “Good.”

Olivia struggled into an upright position, patted her hair and then gave Grace her tea with an air of refinement.

Grace stayed long enough to drink her tea and have a cookie and then left. On her way home, she fought a deepening depression. This was Valentine’s Day, and she was alone again. She’d been alone for the last four years, but this year it felt a hundred times worse. Dan had never been much of a gift-giver. He’d made a few attempts over the years but she couldn’t recall a single Valentine card he’d given her, or flowers.

Buttercup and Sherlock were at the door to greet her. They always showed great enthusiasm about having her home and she rewarded them both with lots of praise and attention. After filling their dishes, she turned on the television. She wasn’t interested in any of the programs, but the TV provided company, the sound of people talking and laughing.

When the doorbell chimed an hour or so later, she didn’t know who it could be. She wasn’t expecting anyone. Opening the front door, she saw Cliff, and her breath caught. After a slight hesitation, while she fortified her resolve, she opened the door.

He waited on her porch, a bouquet of red roses in hand. At this time of year, Grace knew those flowers must have cost a fortune.

Without a word, he opened the screen door and stepped into the house. He held out the roses. “Can we talk?”

The desire to welcome him back into her life felt like an undertow, about to drag her beneath the waves. She took a deep breath as they just stood there, inside her front door. “I love you, Cliff—but no.”

Her answer appeared to shock him. “You won’t even talk to me?”

“Why? So you can apologize and then two weeks or two months down the road repeat the same behavior?”

“No,” he said. “It won’t happen again. You have my word on that.”

She wanted to believe him, but she couldn’t.

He must have felt her indecision. “I love you, Grace.”

“I’m sure you do, but you don’t trust me.”

Cliff removed his Stetson and studied the floor. “I told you what my marriage was like.”

“And I’ve told you I’m not Susan. I made a mistake and I’ve paid dearly for it. I’m sorry, Cliff, truly sorry, but I think you should leave.” Her voice faltered, but her determination didn’t.

He nodded, replacing his hat. “When you said we were through, I thought breaking it off completely might be for the best. What you said was right on target. The way I treated you wasn’t intentional—but in a sense it was. I see that now. I suppose I was hoping you’d put an end to the relationship….”