Cardwell Ranch Trespasser(15)

She’d known Hud for years, ever since she’d moved to Big Sky and met Dana. He was like a brother to her. But when he’d sat down behind his desk just then, she saw him become the marshal, all business. She felt the wall come up between them and had to fight tears of frustration and regret.

Taking a breath, she tried to calm down. But she was at war with herself. She knew he wasn’t going to believe her, but at the same time she had to try to make him see the truth.

“I was asleep. Rick called me.” She told him about the conversation, recalling as much as she could of it.

Hud nodded when she finished. “You said he sounded as if he’d been drinking. He said he would give you ‘the scoop’ on Dee. His words?”

“Yes and the way he said ‘Dee,’ I got the impression she might not really be Dee Anna Justice.” She instantly saw skepticism in Hud’s expression. No doubt Dana had also told him that she thought Hilde was jealous of her cousin. “There is something wrong with Dee. I feel it.”

She quickly regretted blurting it out when Hud said “Hilde” in a tone that made it clear she was too biased against the woman to be credible.

Thank goodness Colt believed her.

“Hud, you have to admit it’s suspicious that he calls, ready to tell me about her, and ends up dead.”

“You said he sounded drunk. He might have already taken enough drugs to kill him. Which would explain why by the time you got there, he was already dead. Also, you have no idea what ‘the scoop’ on her might have been. He was a disgruntled ex-boyfriend.”

“Was he?” she asked. “All we have is Dee’s word on that. I assume she has an alibi?”

“She was at the house. Hilde, she was there all evening.”

She knew Dee was behind it. Maybe she’d put something in the bottle of bourbon that was beside the bed. Or hired someone to kill him. But there was no doubt in Hilde’s mind that she’d killed him.

“Rick was addicted to prescription drugs,” Hud said with a sigh. “Dee said it was one reason she’d broken up with him. She was also worried that he might hurt himself because of the breakup. Apparently she told him after the horseback ride to the lake that they wouldn’t be getting back together.”

Hilde smiled, not surprised that Dee had covered her bases. Again. “She set that up nicely, didn’t she?” she asked, unable to keep the amusement out of her tone.

“Hilde.” His voice reeked with impatience.

She got to her feet, giving up. She’d cried wolf too many times without any proof to back it up. No one believed her. Except Colt. If he was telling the truth. She groaned inwardly at the thought that he might just be indulging her because he liked her. Liked her? Or just wanted to get her into his bed because she was a challenge?

“If those are all your questions...”

“Did you see anyone leaving the motel when you drove up?” Hud asked with a sigh.

She shook her head.

“The motel room door was unlocked?”

She nodded.

“Did you hear anyone going out the back as you entered?”

Why was he doing this? He believed it was an accidental overdose. Was he just trying to get her to see that she was wrong? “I didn’t see anyone. I really can’t tell you any more.”

Hud gave her a regretful look. He knew she was angry that he didn’t believe her, but there was nothing she could do about that.

“She’s after you, Hud.”

“Who?” he asked, frowning.

“Dee. She wants you.”

He got to his feet, angrier now. “Hilde, I don’t know what’s gotten into you. You of all people know how I feel about Dana, about our family.” He shook his head. “Go home and get some rest.”

She nodded, seeing that there was nothing more she could say. “If you have any more questions, you know where I live.” With that she left.

* * *

COLT HAD A pretty good idea how things had gone the moment Hilde answered the door. He’d thought about waiting until morning, but he was worried about her. If things had gone as he suspected they had, she would be upset and might welcome company.

“I just wanted to be sure you were all right.”

She shook her head and motioned him inside. “Dee had an alibi. Not that she needs it. No one believes me anyway. She set this up so perfectly, telling Hud and Dana about Rick’s drug problem and that she was worried he would do something terrible to himself.”

“I’m sorry,” he said. “I believe you.”

“Do you?” She met his gaze with a fiery one of her own. She was good and mad, and she’d never looked more beautiful. He’d only glimpsed this kind of passion in her before tonight. “Or are you just trying to get into my pants?”

He laughed. “As tempting as that offer is, I like to think I have a shot without being forced to lie to you. I believe you, Hilde. It’s too much of a coincidence that he should overdose when you’re on the way to his motel room. She got to him. I’m not sure how, but she got to him.”

Tears filled her eyes. “Why can’t Hud see that?”

“Because Dee’s good at hiding her true self and Hud operates on proof.”

“Colt, I don’t even think she is Dee Anna Justice.”

He raised a brow.

“It’s the way Rick called her ‘Dee.’ I heard him do it on the horseback ride up to the lake. Is there any way to find out if she’s even the woman she says she is?”

Colt gave that some thought. He wasn’t sure he believed Dee was pretending to be Dana’s cousin. He wasn’t sure how she could have pulled that off, but he was willing to put Hilde’s mind at rest and his own.

“I’ll see if I can get her fingerprints. I might need your help.”

“You know you have it,” she said. “Would you like something to drink? I have some wine.”

“You’re tired. I should go.”

“I could use the company. Just one drink.”

He smiled. “If you had a beer...”

“I do.”

He followed her through the house to the kitchen. Her house was neat as a pin and nicely furnished. But not overdone. He realized they had that in common: a minimalistic view of the world.

She handed him a beer, poured herself a glass of wine and led him into the living room.

“Dee already told Dana that Rick had been depressed and she was worried about him, since she told him it was over after the horseback ride,” Hilde said. “I swear she must have been planning to drug him right from the moment he showed up.”

“It’s proving it that’s the problem,” he said. Sitting here in Hilde’s house seemed the most natural thing in the world. “I want you to stay away from her unless I am there to make sure she doesn’t try to kill you again.”

Hilde looked up in surprise. “You can’t believe she would try again. She couldn’t get away with another murder.”

“Rick’s death will probably be ruled an accidental overdose,” he reminded her. “Consider how it would look if something happened to you now. You’ve been having a streak of bad luck. Plus you’ve been...overwrought.” She started to object, but he held up his hand. “I’m just saying how Dee would spin it. You got careless, you haven’t been yourself. You get the idea. That’s why I want you to give the woman a wide berth until she leaves.”

“She’s not leaving.”

“Well, she can’t stay forever.”

“She can if she finds a way to get Hud all to herself,” Hilde said. “I told Hud that Dee was after him.”

Colt groaned. “I can imagine how he took that.”

“He needed to be warned.”

Colt couldn’t argue that. He just hoped it wouldn’t have the opposite effect and make Hud more sympathetic to Dee.

“She knows we’re onto her.” Hilde drained her wineglass. “What scares me is what she’ll do next. I’m afraid for Dana and her family. If she makes a play for Hud... I have a feeling Dee doesn’t take rejection well.”

Colt agreed that the whole family could be in danger. “I wish there was some way to get her out of that house.”

“I doubt dynamite would work, even if Dana would let you blast her out. Dee has completely snowed Dana.”

He could hear her disappointment. “I know it’s frustrating seeing Dana and even Hud taken in like this. But you have to admit, Dee is good.”

“She’s playing this perfectly, too perfectly,” Hilde said. “Which makes me think this isn’t her first time she’s done this.”

“Whatever this is,” Colt said. “I’ll see what I can find out about her. Meanwhile, I’ll see what we can do about getting her fingerprints.” He’d have to be careful. He couldn’t let Hud find out that he was investigating his wife’s cousin. If Dana wasn’t so happy having found a cousin she never knew she had, then Colt was sure Hud would be suspicious of Dee by now.