The Truth About Alice(40)

Alice sat down at the kitchen table, so I did, too. She stared at the 88 and then back at me. “But I’m not, I mean … I’m not paying you to do this. Why would you.…” She stopped, and her cheeks pinked up a bit. Alice knows I’m attracted to her. She knows and she knows I know she knows. Even earlier in the fall when she’d asked me if I was only tutoring her because I wanted to sleep with her, she must have known deep down inside that I liked her.

Hadn’t she realized that as time went by, it wasn’t simply sex that I thought about? (Although I would be a hypocrite and a liar if I didn’t admit to frequently fantasizing about such unattainable acts in the privacy of my own home.) Hadn’t she’d figured out by now that I really like her—her, Alice? Not Fantasy Alice, but the living, breathing, talking, walking, actual Alice who holds her breath near cemeteries and eats grilled cheese sandwiches and has managed to survive complete and utter banishment from everyone she ever regarded as a friend and still come to school every single day.

That Alice. I like her. I like being her friend.

Alice didn’t humiliate me. She didn’t make me elaborate. She just sat there, pink cheeks, 88 in hand.

“Alice, I know that I’m not … I mean, that I’m not exactly what you’d find…” I could not find the words. I have a genius IQ, yet I could not find the words.

Alice could. She reached out across the kitchen table and put her small girl hand on top of my arm, and the warmth that pulsed from that touch heated up my entire body from my toes to the roots of my hair.

“Kurt, it’s okay. I want you to know that I don’t know what I would have done this year without you. And I don’t mean just math. I mean, that was great. But what I mean is that you were the only person in the school who would even talk to me. You were my friend, Kurt. You are my friend. And I don’t have any friends other than you. None. I don’t know if you know what that feels like,” she said, and as she said it, her voice broke a bit.

“Yes,” I said. “I do. I know exactly what that feels like.”

Alice looked ashamed as if she should have predicted such an answer. She glanced down and blushed harder.

“Of course you know,” she said. “I suck, I’m sorry. God, until everything happened, I never even gave you the time of day.”

“That’s not true,” I said. “When I helped you with your Geometry that one time in the library back in tenth grade, you were very nice to me.”

Alice let go of my hand and wiped away the tears that were beginning to fall.

“Oh sure, I was nice, but I just…” she hesitated. “I saw you as this weird nerd. This weird nerd who could be useful to me in the moment. I probably wouldn’t have been nice to you otherwise. I’m sorry, but that’s the truth. You can hate me for admitting it.”

It hurt to hear despite knowing it was the truth, but I didn’t hate Alice. I couldn’t and I can’t.

“I don’t think someone like Elaine O’Dea would have been nice to me,” I argued. “Even if she only saw me as a useful nerd. You must have known that I would have helped you with your Geometry regardless. The fact that you were nice to me even when you didn’t have to be … I mean, that has to count for something, right?”

Alice slowed down her crying and smiled at me.

“Kurt, you’re too nice. I’m not a saint, you know. I’ve done some stupid, messed up stuff in my life.”

“I know,” I told her. “But it’s not like my motives were entirely pure.”

“What do you mean?”

I stared at my shoes, swallowed hard and said, “Well, I did want to help you with your math, that’s true. But I don’t think I would have done it if I hadn’t thought you were so beautiful.”

Alice didn’t say anything for what seemed like an unfairly long amount of time. Then she asked me, “So … if I got attacked by a mountain lion and my face was all gross and disfigured, and, like, ripped to shreds, you wouldn’t have helped me with my math homework?” I think maybe she was trying not to laugh.

“Truth?” I said, digging around for the courage to look at her. “In the beginning, no. I wouldn’t have. But now you could go out and get mauled by twenty mountain lions, and I would still want to help you. I would still want to be your friend. You’re a great person, Alice. You’re not just beautiful.”

Alice smiled her wide smile. The crooked incisor smile.

“Well I guess we’ve both, like, evolved or whatever.” She chuckled and then stood up with a long exhale and a stretch of her arms. “I’m sorry, but this conversation calls for shitty beer.”

I nodded in agreement and took the cold can of Lone Star that Alice handed me from the refrigerator. She popped her can open and took a sip.

“I’m so glad you want to be my friend,” she laughed. “Even though I’ve had seven abortions and slept with the principal and plotted to have Brandon Fitzsimmons murdered by Mafia hit men before killing him with my dirty texting, right?” Alice rolled her eyes. It was the first time she’d ever said his name out loud in front of me, and suddenly, I knew it was time. It had to be now or never.

“Alice, about Brandon Fitzsimmons,” I said, and I took another sip of beer in an effort not to lose courage. “There’s something I’ve been meaning to tell you. Something I think you’d like to know.”