The Lies I Tell(68)
“How did Melody end up with it?”
“He sold it to her for $20,000, which is a fraction of what it’s worth. Melody said he could buy it back after the settlement was finalized, then sell it again, this time at market value.”
“Surely he would have known he’d be slammed with taxes,” I said, my mind half on what Renata was saying, half on how she might have convinced Ron to go along with something similar.
“Melody said she knew a way to get around them. Another lie. But by that point, the only thing Phillip cared about was hanging on to what he believed was his,” she explained. “He didn’t think beyond the settlement. Melody convinced him it would work simply because she’d told him it had worked for her.”
“Con artists often target people who are emotionally vulnerable,” I said. “People who need to believe the reality they’re selling, desperate for a solution to whatever problems they’re facing.”
“She ruined his life. His reputation,” Renata said. I knew what Meg would say. He ruined his own life. I just found all the cracks.
“Has he contacted the police?” I asked her.
“He did, obviously, but they said she’d be ‘hard to prosecute.’ Their words. Because he’d been engaging in fraudulent behavior as well, it would be hard to prove she conned him. His divorce attorneys resigned and he was forced to represent himself. It was a mess.”
It was hard for me to muster any sympathy for Phillip Montgomery. Renata gave me his ex-wife’s name and number, and I called her next. Celia revealed a man who terrorized her and her children. “I stayed longer than I should have,” she told me. “I left with just a suitcase of essentials. Phillip was livid. Changed the locks. Wouldn’t allow me to enter the house to retrieve the rest of my things. By the time we got a court order, most of it was gone. Thrown out, donated, sold, I don’t know. I didn’t care about my clothes, but some of the more sentimental pieces—my mother’s jewelry, notes and cards the kids gave me over the years—that gutted me.”
So much of her story was familiar, Meg and her mother having lived their own version of it. “How do you think Meg found you?”
“No idea. But here’s the crazy thing—a few weeks ago, I was contacted by a real estate attorney who was working on behalf of a counterpart in California. He told me the lake house had been deeded to me. And since I acquired it after our divorce was finalized, Phillip can’t touch it. It’s mine.”
I sat up straight, my pen still. “Meg gave you the house?”
“And everything in it,” Celia said. “Even the taxes were covered.”
I was unable to speak for a moment, Meg’s generosity unexpected, and yet, not surprising. Sure, she’d kept Phillip’s cash. But she balanced the scales. Gave back to Celia a little bit of the power Phillip had stolen, and exposed him in the process. The same thing she’d done for Kristen. What she was trying to do now for her mother and for herself.
“The incredible thing,” Celia continued, “is that right before all of this happened, I’d resigned myself to getting nothing. I was ready to quit. To let Phillip keep it all.”
“Why?” I asked.
“Divorce is like a virus. It invades every corner of your life, every thought and every moment. Everything is viewed through the lens of how will this benefit or harm my settlement. It’s toxic.”
“But you’d have given up a lot of money,” I pressed.
“How much is your freedom worth to you?”
***
I’m still trying to answer that question. It’s a complicated shame to have someone you trust deceive you, the pain of that betrayal compounded by the unraveling of the life you thought you’d have. The removal of their belongings, the empty spaces left behind to remind you of all you never saw. Telling friends and family, the phone calls and texts where you have to carry everyone else’s regrets alongside your own. Which is why the only person I’ve told so far is Jenna.
She’d said all the right things, been outraged on my behalf. “I hope you’ve gone to the police.”
First, I had to drop the charges Scott filed against Meg.
***
I sit on hold for fifteen minutes before I get someone on the line.
“Hi, I filed a police report a few weeks ago, but there was a misunderstanding, and I want to drop it.”
“Case number?”
I read it off and am ready to wait while she looks it up, but she says, “That’s not a case number. It’s generally a ten-digit number, found in the upper right corner of your copy of the police report.”
I look at the report Scott had brought home for me to sign. Eight digits and a letter.
“Let me call you back,” I tell her.
Of course, there was never a real police report. If he’d actually filed one, the investigation would have eventually cleared Meg and implicated him. But a bigger realization keeps me from being angry about another lie. No police report means I’m still the only person who knows who Meg is and what she’s doing.
I grab my phone and text Meg, hoping it’s not too late. That she isn’t already gone. Thanks for giving me the space I needed to sort things out on my end. I’m ready to get back to work.
But my phone stays silent. I get up and go into the kitchen to grab a soda, and when I return, I decide to read through my notes from Celia and Renata, trying to see a thread between what Meg did to Phillip Montgomery and what she might have done to Ron. A forged inspection report? A falsified appraisal? Pretending to be private buyers guarding their identity, and then possibly stealing the Canyon Drive property back. I can’t even be sure that the sale price was $4.5 million. Meg could have told me anything, knowing that information wouldn’t be public for weeks.