Tell Me Pretty Lies(8)

“Fine?” I say with a shrug, but it comes out sounding more like a question. She lifts a brow. “Nothing I wasn’t expecting,” I amend, giving her a slightly more honest answer.

Ms. Thomas nods knowingly. “I can imagine. Your situation is certainly…unique.”

I snort. That’s putting it lightly.

“Have you talked to anyone?”

I cut my eyes at her. “You mean, like a therapist?”

She nods again.

“No.”

“Is that something you’re open to?”

“Not especially. Why am I here?”

She frowns, not understanding what it is that I’m asking.

“I’m not the one who should be here,” I clarify. I highly doubt Holden or Christian has to meet with a counselor.

“You know I’m not allowed to discuss other students with you,” she starts, choosing her words carefully. “You’ve been gone a while. I just want to make sure you’re adjusting well.”

“Well, like I said, I’m fine.” I can’t keep the defensiveness out of my tone.

“Hmm.” She cocks her head to the side, considering something. I avert my eyes, focusing on the collage of cheesy, inspirational quotes pinned to her wall instead and bouncing my knee.

“Those came with the office.” She motions to the signage behind her.

“Right.” Makes sense. She’s not exactly Oprah.

“What about a diary?”

My foot stops its incessant bouncing. “A diary,” I repeat, skepticism lacing my tone.

“Diary, journal, whatever you want to call it.” She waves a hand through the air.

I shake my head, dismissing the idea. “I don’t see how that would accomplish anything.”

It’s her turn to shrug. “It’s therapeutic, sometimes, to get it all out. Even if no one will ever see it. It will also push you to be…introspective.”

I can practically hear the unspoken second half of that statement. Instead of pretending like nothing happened.

“I’ll think about it,” I say to pacify her, then stand to leave.

“I’ll be frank with you,” she says, stopping me in my tracks. I pause, waiting for her to continue. “I’m supposed to meet with you on a weekly basis—”

My mouth drops open. Did my mom put her up to this? “That’s a little excessive,” I say, cutting her off.

“I agree.” She surprises me by saying. “So how about a compromise?”

I cross my arms, unhappy with where this is going. “Such as?”

She leans over to open a desk drawer, pulling out a black composition notebook, then holds it out in offering. “Instead of dragging you in here every week, you write in this instead. You’ll check back in with me every other week. I won’t read a word you write,” she promises. “As long as I can see that you are writing, that’s good enough for me.”

“That’s it?” I ask, waiting for the catch.

“You don’t have to talk before you’re ready, and I don’t have to waste my lunch break trying to make you. Fair trade, I’d say.”

You are the worst guidance counselor, ever. And I’m thankful for it.

I hesitate, weighing my options. Be forced into baring my soul to an unqualified high school guidance counselor, or scribble in a notebook every once in a while? It’s a no-brainer.

She lifts a brow, extending the notebook further, prompting me to take it. My shoulders deflate, and she smiles, knowing she’s won.

“Fine.”

“Come back and see me in two days. Then, every other week from there on out.”

I mumble a thanks, then turn for the door when her voice stops me again.

“And Shayne?”

I pause, looking at her over my shoulder. She leans in, lowering her voice. “I was a student here once, too. I know better than anyone how brutal these entitled assholes can be.”

My eyebrows shoot up to my hairline and I almost crack a smile. I did not see that coming.

“So if you ever need to talk…” She leaves the invitation hanging and I give her a grateful nod before closing the door. Stepping out into the now-busy hall, I fish my phone out of my back pocket to text Valen, but she beats me to it.

Valen: Eating on campus. Meet me in the cafeteria.

I groan, internally debating on ditching school for the first time. To my right are the double doors that lead to the cafeteria. To the left is the exit. My phone vibrates in my hand, interrupting my thoughts.

Valen: Don’t even think about bailing.

I groan, stuffing my phone back into my pocket, and reluctantly make my way toward the cafeteria. Apprehension settles in, growing with each step, but I shove it down and square my shoulders. It’s not that I can’t handle it—I’m more than used to being a spectacle. Being the new girl in a small town is bad enough, but living with the Ames brothers was another thing entirely. Everyone either hated me because they were jealous or they wanted to befriend me in an attempt to weasel their way into the brothers’ inner circle. And their pants. Everyone, that is, except Valen.

So, no. It’s not the whispers and jokes and stares I’m worried about. It’s the unknown that unsettles me, and this is just another giant question mark in my life. Without Thayer, Holden, and Danny, where do I belong? Best-case scenario—the masses will no longer perceive me as a threat nor an in, and I’ll become invisible. Worst-case? The gloves will come off, now that I’m not in their good graces.