Tell Me Pretty Lies(40)

He’s taking me to his room? My stomach flips, and not because of the alcohol. It’s been a long time since I’ve been in here, and I’m not sure I want to be now. Thayer kicks the door shut behind him, then stalks to the center of his room and tosses me onto the bed.

I yelp, bouncing onto his mattress, throwing my arms out behind me out of reflex. Thayer’s eyes flit down my body, landing on my exposed underwear, and I quickly jerk my dress down, clamping my legs shut around my hand.

“What is wrong with you? You just hauled me up here like a jealous boyfriend! Do you realize what this looks like?”

“Why should I give a fuck what they think? I just saved your ass.”

“Saved me?” I snort, incredulous. “Or was it just a part of your grand scheme to get close to me?” I use air quotes to drive my point home, but Thayer doesn’t react like I thought he would. He doesn’t seem like he’s been caught. I push to my feet, closing the distance between us. “It wasn’t real, was it?”

“What wasn’t?”

“Any of it. You fixing my car. Giving me the key to the barn. Holden,” I tick off. “You made him pretend to be my friend. And for what?” What did he hope to accomplish?

“I told him to watch you,” he clarifies. “Big deal.”

“Like that’s so much better.”

“I’m not sorry, Shayne.”

“Of course you’re not.”

“I needed to know if I could trust you.”

“And?” I ask, raising an eyebrow, challenging.

“Jury’s still out.”

“Great talk. Don’t you have to get back to Lissa?” I realize my mistake the moment the words leave my lips. Thayer scrapes his teeth across his bottom lip, capturing his piercing.

“Now look who’s jealous,” he accuses, moving in on me.

“Just an observation.”

He hooks a finger underneath the strap on my shoulder, sliding it back and forth under the thin material, teasing. I slap his hand away, not wanting him to see how he affects me, even when he’s acting like an irrational, unbearable asshole.

Pounding at the door has both our heads snapping toward the sound. “Shayne, are you okay?” Valen’s voice calls out, a mixture of irritation and worry.

“Make her leave,” he says, low enough so only I can hear.

“Why should I?”

“Because this doesn’t involve her.”

“What is this?” I ask. I feel like everyone around me is in on something I’m not.

“You have questions?”

I nod.

“Get rid of her and I’ll tell you what you need to know.”

“She didn’t drive here. We walked from my house. I’m not letting her leave alone.”

“We’ll get her home safe.”

“You’ll answer my questions?”

“I said I’ll tell you what you need to know.”

I purse my lips, looking into his stormy eyes. “No deal.”

Valen pounds again. “I’m two seconds from calling the police.”

“No, she’s not!” Holden yells, amusement clear in his voice.

“Give that back!”

The sounds of them tussling on the other side of the door tells me that he took her phone.

Thayer narrows his eyes. “Fine. I’ll answer your questions.”

I smile, victorious. “I’m fine!”

“Not good enough. I want to see that you’re okay,” Valen’s muffled voice calls out.

My heart swells and my chest fills with pride. I’ve subjected her to enough horror stories for her to walk away without seeing for herself. Not that Thayer’s capable of any of those things. But rule number one? You never truly know anyone. Rule number two? Never, under any circumstance, leave your friend alone in a potentially dangerous situation.

I move past Thayer and pull the door open. Valen’s eyes are full of suspicion as she glances between us, then pushes the door open to scan the room.

“I’m fine, I promise.”

“You’re soaking wet,” she points out.

“Don’t look at me like that. Ryan Matthews doused her with beer, then tried to stick his tongue down her throat,” Thayer explains.

Valen raises her eyebrows, looking at me for confirmation. I roll my eyes, then nod. “I’ll explain everything tomorrow, okay?”

She crosses her arms, seeming to mull it over. “Better be one hell of an explanation,” she relents.

“Where’s Christian?” Thayer asks Holden.

“He and Baker are getting rid of Ryan.”

“Kick everyone out, then take her home.”

“Gladly.” He grins, handing Valen’s phone back to her. She jerks it from his hand, giving him a scathing look.

“No thanks. I’d rather crawl home.”

Holden’s eyes flash with a wicked gleam. “That could be arranged.”

“Valen, please let him take you.” Holden isn’t a threat. Conniving and manipulative, sure, but not dangerous. She knows that, too. She’s just being stubborn—not that I blame her.

“Fine.” She turns for the stairs, making it halfway down before she turns back around. “Well? Are you coming?”