Her Last Day (Jessie Cole #1)(63)

She nodded. “I’m four years older than Sophie. She was sixteen when she got pregnant. By the time Olivia was born, Dad’s drinking had gotten out of hand, and I knew I needed to get a job and find somewhere else to live. I could make the most money as a cocktail waitress, so that’s what I did. And then I lucked out when I met a guy who said he had a run-down house in Midtown. We made a deal. He’d keep the rent low if I agreed not to ask him to fix leaky faucets or creaky wooden steps.” She sighed. “We’ve been here ever since.”

“And Sophie and Olivia moved in with you right away?”

“Yes. Sophie needed to finish high school, so I took care of Olivia during the day, and Sophie took over at night. I was too busy and too tired to worry about life dreams.”

“And then Sophie disappeared.”

“In the blink of an eye, it seemed.”

“And that brings me to the reason I came here today,” he said.

She waited.

“I want to talk to you about Sophie’s last day.”

When Ben Morrison had first contacted her, Jessie had been worried about Olivia, but she’d also worried about whether she could handle starting over again. In the past, every time new evidence was brought to her attention, she would start from the beginning and find herself reliving the nightmare. But after hearing Olivia talk about needing to know what happened to Sophie, she’d had a change of heart and found herself thinking that maybe this time things would be different.

“Would you rather do this another time?”

“No,” she said. “Let’s do this now.”

He pulled a manila file from his case. He then slipped a ring from his finger and set it on the table in front of her.

She picked it up. “What’s this?”

“I believe it’s the same ring the man who followed Sophie out of the Wild West was wearing the night she disappeared.”

She dropped it as if it were on fire. It clinked and then rolled across the table. “How? Where did you find it?”

“I’ll explain, but if you don’t mind, I’d rather start from the beginning.”

“Go ahead.”

“As you know, I’ve been seeing images—flashbacks, if you will—which could be the return of some forgotten memories, which possibly include remnants of things I saw when I was reporting on one case or another before the accident.”

“Okay,” she said anxiously.

“When we were talking to Leanne Baxter at the Wild West the other day, she mentioned a skull ring. No sooner were the words out of her mouth than my head felt as if it were about to explode—”

“I remember. You excused yourself for a few minutes.”

“That’s right.”

She did her best to sit quietly and listen.

“Months after my accident, after I was released from the hospital, the lead investigator called me into her office and showed me objects that were found at the scene of the crash. A pocketknife, two rings, some coins, and a key. She wanted to see if any of the items belonged to me, but she also hoped that one of the objects might help bring back memories of that night.”

“But that didn’t happen? The objects meant nothing to you?”

“No. Not until Leanne mentioned the skull ring.”

It took a second for it all to sink in. Jessie straightened. “I don’t understand—wait a minute. Are you telling me that whoever was in the car with you on the night of your accident”—she pointed at the skull ring on the table in front of her—“was wearing this ring?”

He nodded.

She felt the blood rush from her face. “But that would mean you were the other man Leanne saw walk out of the bar that night.”

“I’m left to assume the same thing,” he said.

Jessie jumped from her chair, grimacing from the pain that caused, since she was still bruised and sore from the attack. “This is crazy.”

He said nothing.

She pointed an accusing finger at him. “You were there,” she said, unable to fully comprehend what he’d just told her.

He nodded.

Unable to contain her anger and frustration, she felt her hands shaking. “So where the hell is she?”

“I don’t know.”

“Oh, come on.” She pushed her hair out of her face. “How convenient. My sister walks out of a bar after midnight. Two men follow her. One of those men is now dead, and my sister is missing. The one man who survives, the one man who holds all the answers, happens to have amnesia.”

“I’m as frustrated as you.”

“No, I don’t think you are,” she told him. “I’ve been raising a young girl for the past ten years—a young girl who has no idea who her father is—or who her mother is, for that matter, or why she disappeared. Not a day goes by that I don’t wonder what I could have done differently to stop Sophie from leaving the house that night. Have you ever felt so much guilt that it eats at you every single day until you feel less than whole? I don’t think anyone truly knows what it’s like to have someone you love go missing unless it happens to them.”

“You’re right. I’m sorry.”

She drew in a breath, tried to calm herself by taking a seat again. “So you must know who this ring belongs to. What’s his name?”